Case Study 1:
Breaking Barriers: One School's Path to Academic Acceleration and Student Success
Robinson G. Jones: A Four-Star School
In this case study, we showcase one of our partner schools, Robinson G. Jones, for which we have provided direct executive coaching and training through professional learning for the past five years. Their story exemplifies strong leadership, dedicated teachers, a shared commitment to student success using data and centering students, equity, and excellence, which are all strong tenants of our Five Course Framework.
Their story epitomizes what happens when leaders and educators in a community embrace and execute a shared vision through collective efficacy.
The District
The Cleveland Metropolitan School District (CMSD) is Ohio's third-largest public school system, serving more than 36,000 students, many of whom come from economically disadvantaged households and are students of color. Under The Cleveland Plan, a groundbreaking reform plan created by the community and written into state law, CMSD strives to ensure every child receives a high-quality education. Historically, students have faced low academic achievement; however, the district has embraced a multi-faceted strategic plan that maintains transparency, involves all stakeholders, and ensures a commitment to the values of diversity, inclusivity, and equity. The district has made significant strides in achievement and attendance and envisions closing the gap between where they are and where they want to be. This is outlined in the new comprehensive CMSD Strategic Plan, launched in 2023 and designed to improve academic achievement for all students, focusing on drastically increasing proficiency rates.
The Challenge
“Centering students and folding their arms differently - a reference to taking different action in schools for better results- actively embraced the Just-in-Time instruction approach into instructional delivery. Just-in-Time instruction (JIT) refers to a teaching method that delivers educational content exactly when students need it, often in response to an immediate task, problem, or learning gap. It contrasts with traditional teaching models where content is delivered in advance and often without immediate relevance. The goal of JIT instruction is to provide timely and contextualized learning that enhances understanding and retention.”
The SOLUTION
“Equity Matters guided the development of common language, explicitly naming terminology such as trauma awareness, remediation, academic acceleration, unfinished learning, and compounded learning loss. They also helped in solidifying which assessments would serve instructional, predictive, or evaluative purposes across the school. Together they were instrumental in understanding how to use assessments to advance student learning while using the data to expose places where students had gaps in access to grade-level content.”
“A challenge was naming our approach and addressing the age-old adage of remediation. We had to be intentional about not falling into the remediation trap when students are not reading or engaging on grade level. Equity Matters supported us with real-time practical strategies that helped us to move beyond the “why” of academic acceleration to the “how.”
“We know that equity means ensuring all students have access to high-quality, rigorous, grade-level appropriate materials and instruction. One way to ensure that is to assess how students perform at grade level.”
“My student “M” was in 4th grade when Sonya Murray walked into my school explaining to me that my Special Education students (all students) needed to be exposed to grade-level curriculum. That was the moment my teaching philosophy changed and my students excelled. I need you to know how many lives you have changed.”
“We focused on problem-solving across barriers such as mindsets, mental models, and any practices that were hindering students from reaching higher levels.”
“We are continuing to work on improving our communication and narrowing our focus, as we recognize that if left unaddressed, we could easily revert to the comfort of remediation, a practice that is all too familiar when students struggle with reading or engaging with grade-level math tasks.”
The RESULTS
“We saw that the approach to a grade-level strategy was what students needed during the pandemic and beyond, which has impacted data strategy and our instructional impact. Our successful adaptation to grade level expectations for all through data strategy reassured us of the resilience and adaptability of students and our teachers. The sky is now our limit. ”
The School
Robinson G. Jones (RG Jones) is one of the Cleveland Metropolitan School District (CMSD) PreK-8 schools serving students on the west side of Cleveland. The student population is 419, and the school's minority student enrollment is 67%. The student population comprises 47% female students and 53% male students. There are 27 equivalent full-time teachers. Robinson G. Jones focuses on providing a supportive environment where students can thrive academically and socially. CMSD has been working on significant reforms to improve the quality of education, and Robinson G. Jones is part of that broader effort.
In 2019-2020, RG Jones’s state assessment scores were well below state performance levels, and the school’s leader, Ms. Melissa Watts, desired a more robust teaching and learning strategy that would lead to greater student outcomes. RG Jones was a “last chance” school which means the school was one of the lowest performing with a last chance for progress.
Ms. Watts partnered with Equity Matters, and together we established a clear vision for the school, aiming to enhance academic acceleration, data strategy, and instructional practice. Under Ms. Watts’ leadership, the school set a goal to become a premier institution in the Cleveland Metropolitan School District. A new instructional push focused on accelerated learning and a shift to standards-based instruction that centered on grade-level expectations for all students. Dr. Sonya Murray served as the consultant, facilitating bi-monthly intensive training and support in core areas of Math, Science and ELA for all teachers and staff, and became a part of the RG Jones school family.
RG Jones Team in 2018
The new direction would mandate a change in RG Jones educators’ mindset on how to support students not on grade level. With guidance from Equity Matters, through a tailored and customized approach they engaged in a joyful retreat concentrating on self, the current climate and data asking the following questions: “Do I fundamentally believe students can achieve at high levels?” How can I provide strategies to better address the needs of the whole child?
From our early Five-Course Framework conversations, the team embraced strategies to address mental models and deficit thinking. Driven by a desire to challenge low expectations and the current status of the school, the team used a SWOT Analysis to confront the reality of their school's status and ability to meet the needs of all students. Principal Melissa Watts, Assistant Principal RahSheen Clay, Equity Matters Consultant Sonya Murray and the school’s staff were on a journey toward equity and academic excellence for all students.
During the first two years of our partnership, Principal Watts, worked closely with the Dr. Murray to define strategy, align structures, and adjust the staff’s habitual instructional behaviors. This work began with establishing a vision and mission that continues to govern the school. RG Jones staff worked to identify instructional priorities and subsequent habits to maintain, eliminate, or modify to enhance quality and consistency, and implemented strategies to monitor and enforce these changes.
At RG Jones, this initial shift included a shared commitment to:
Offering mini-lessons or tutorials right before students began a related activity.
Providing resources or guidance as students encounter difficulties or new challenges.
Using formative assessments to identify gaps and then delivering targeted instruction based on those findings.
There were grumblings and some were weary of the new path, but the team persevered guided by what was possible. The approach they embraced made learning more efficient by focusing on immediate needs rather than overwhelming learners with information that may not be directly applicable at the time.
The RG Jones staff recognized that a different approach to trauma was critical and so they coupled the approach to student well being with the JIT approach, RG Jones prioritized addressing the impact of trauma on students through responsive strategies. Every session they ended their time with the question, “How can we take action on what we learned?” They humanized their approach to student support by exploring ways to increase collaboration across management, curriculum, and assessment functions.
Some topics explored were:
Trauma Matters
Consistency: Student + Teacher Relationships Matter
Building Safe and Healthy Student Relationships
Restorative Practices to Address Trauma
With the invaluable support of Equity Matters, the school convened an Academic Acceleration & Assessment Plan. Principal Melissa Watts, Equity Matters Lead Consultant Dr. Kristen Taylor, Equity Matters Consultant Dr. Sheldon McAfee and CEO/Founder Dr. Sonya Murray began designing assessment strategies making assessment actionable to improve achievement for all students. As a result, RG Jones staff refocused on including instructional structures enabling teachers to teach so students could learn, using data to uncover where students needed support to inform instruction better.
In addition, the new approach would inform how teachers should adjust when students are not learning. Also, the RG Jones team explored how educators can be more intentional and act with purpose. This work empowered the RG Jones staff to build their knowledge and expertise and make recommendations to enhance quality and streamline their academic approaches so all students could thrive.
"We developed our current academic acceleration strategy and baked it in data strategy, which created a streamlined approach across our school," says Principal Watts, "based on the idea that academic acceleration is an educational equity strategy."
Armed with the vision and change in practice, RG Jones staff, in collaboration with Equity Matters, worked together to create a multi-year plan to implement academic acceleration. They knew this work would take time as change takes time, but they knew they had to be clear about coherence, clarity, and a focus on core instruction. RG Jones wanted to be clear about the need for intentionality and data strategy, understanding that strategic direction, pace, internalization, implementation, and refinement would lead them to their goals.
One intentional strategy employed by RG Jones staff was the use of collective efficacy to achieve their goals collaboratively. They firmly believed they could succeed, and they did. Recognizing that they were not meeting their goals with "WIN" strategies and denying students access to academic acceleration while using remediation approaches, they decided to restructure and adopt a more intentional, streamlined approach to academic acceleration. The staff acknowledged that their lack of role clarity, fragmentation, and unclear focus on academic acceleration were preventing them from moving forward cohesively. RG Jones increased collaboration across assessment strategy, curriculum implementation, and assessment functions, all in service of teaching and learning. This year, EM consultants Dr. Kristen Taylor and Dr. Sonya Murray are providing extensive support to teachers to help take the school to greater heights.
RG Jones students are performing at higher levels overall, which is a testament to their commitment to educational equity and academic excellence.
RG Jones has been awarded four stars by the Ohio State Department, recognizing their comprehensive approach to education, including five stars for gap closing, signifying success in reducing disparities in student performance.
RG Jones was recently recognized as the second highest-performing school in the State of Ohio by the Greater Cleveland Council for its new and stronger communication structures and practices.
RG Jones teaching staff has successfully developed and implemented academic acceleration practices across the school, regardless of students’ grade level. This commitment allows teachers to spend more time understanding student learning, making "just-in-time" adjustments to their teaching practices, and reassuring their confidence and commitment to student success.
RG Jones staff are clear on school priorities, are supportive of the vision, and are confident in the use of data.
3rd grade Achievement results
2019-2024
4th grade Achievement results
2019-2024
5th grade Achievement results
2019-2024
6th grade Achievement results
2019-2024
7th grade Achievement results
2019-2024
8th grade Achievement results
2019-2024
On a 2020-2021 survey Equity Matters provided training for staff and coaching of leadership with the following agreed or strongly agreeing choices:
95%
97%
99%
of staff clearly expressed appreciation for EM support in understanding their instructional priorities and assessment strategy.
of staff supported the school’s vision and found EM support overwhelmingly beneficial in the embrace of academic acceleration.
of staff felt Equity Matter's collaboration and leadership support directly improved teaching learning.
Want to learn more about the improved student outcomes that resulted from a partnership with Equity Matters?
Get K-12 Education Resources and stay connected!
Subscribe to our newsletter to join our community and receive monthly selections of actionable resources and stories of best practices from across our team and work!